Obsidian earns raves for local-first reliability, speed, and Markdown flexibility, with many praising its powerful linking, graph view, and an extensive plugin ecosystem that scales from simple notes to full knowledge systems. Some mention a learning curve and occasional friction on mobile or search, but most say it “just works” and adapts to varied workflows. Maker reviewers add depth: makers of
Markdown language acceptance, preference for keyboard control of applications, command-centred UI, scale for customisation and community plug-ins
How customizable are themes without editing code?
You can download themes that others have created. I can't code, but it's pretty basic code so you can customise it quite easily.
Does mobile editing feel fast and dependable?
I haven't tried it yet, but I intend to once I get Obsidian Sync.
Does Obsidian replace your previous note-taking tool effectively?
Yes, it does. I need to do more work to maintain Obsidian, but it's necessary work that's good practice for strong organisational skills and effectiveness in the long-term.
Infinitely customizable - if you want to make it an incredibly stripped down snippet collector, Zettelkasten, or series of shower thoughts with nothing but Markdown, you can. If you want to install 60 community plugins and move on to the ones that aren't in the Community store yet, customize it with CSS, and have a widget-y dashboard with buttons and dropdown menus, you can do that too. (I'm somewhere in between.) But more to the point, it's a heck of a lot better than spreading all my notes to myself between 30232340 notepad .txt files in different folders, Notion, Docs and Notes on my phone.
Has it fixed the ADHD and the tendency to pick up every new productivity software? Nope, but that's my own issue. Has it greatly helped with consolidating and getting me into a routine? It sure has -- and it also has the really cool bonus of encouraging wikilinks within notes, which scratches a hypertext itch I forgot I had. (Also, there's a really robust TTRPG community within the Obsidian forums/Discord and a whooole subsection of user-made tips for GMs and players, so that's a nice little bonus for those of you into that hobby.)
What's great
note-taking (1)community support (1)markdown support (21)strong community (1)community plugins (41)customization (28)
I’ve been using Obsidian daily for over a year now. There’s no onboarding funnel, no update pop-ups, no pressure to upgrade. It just works, and it keeps working.
You let some tools into your life without thinking too hard about it. Obsidian was like that, although I did spend probably an entire week customizing it, iterating upon a template until I figured out how to structure my daily notes versus larger long-term projects. I mean, I was not really just getting into a note-taking app, I was actually looking for a new way to structure my thoughts and create meaningful habits around journaling.
I really like that Obsidian doesn't get in the way once you customize it how you like. It's usually the first thing I open in the morning, so I can plan the whole day ahead of me, journal my thoughts, and take notes for my meetings without it being overly complicated.