Does Product Hunt need a private message feature?
sulyman moyo
35 replies
I personally feel Product Hunt needs a no link Private chat to make connecting with other makers easier.
What do you think?
Replies
Bogomil Shopov - Бого@bogomep
Threat Modeling e-book
Nope :)
Share
Threat Modeling e-book
@repreneur because we had it and it was full with spam and requests about supporting a launch and more. That's why it was discontinued!
AI With Vibes
AI With Vibes
AnythingLLM
It actually used to exist, but as others have pointed out PH is about the community and not the individual links! People have Twitter to connect person-to-person. The more open discussions are, the better quality they have the opportunity to become!
AI With Vibes
@tim_carambat Interesting comment
i never knew it existed actually
Open discussions help me a lot also
No way, everything has DMs now, I would never see them and lose important connections
keypup.io
Interesting question. I don't think PH needs a DM feature. Otherwise, it will just become a LinkedIn for makers. Discussions are a great way to share here on PH. With DMs I'm scared to be spammed with people promoting their product and asking for upvotes.
AI With Vibes
@cica_laure_mbappe The fear is something i've noticed but PH Has a points system and the Points shows how long and active you are. How about using those points to DM for example it costs 50 points to open a chat and you can also choose to turn on or off the feature
BTW I love Kylian Mbappe Dope Name you have
yes. I agree with you.
AI With Vibes
@new_user_241f15afc1 Exactly No links, No attachment = No spam
No, there is Twitter. I dont need another one
AI With Vibes
@robinkunz Twitter DM's Are crazy nowadays
Nope dont think its a good idea
@repreneur it will invite a lot of spammer, community is better this way IMO if anyone spams the DEV's can easily take action
AI With Vibes
@manish_rawat1 Why if i may ask
AI With Vibes
@manish_rawat1 Great point
I think that will fade out the essence of open communities on PH. It's good to be transparent and open about asking and helping!
AI With Vibes
@siddhesh_lokare1 I get the idea behind this, it's more or less PH branding
Being an open community it's good that the feature isn't present.
AI With Vibes
@arjuunajith Yeah the branding aspect
InAppStory
I think that the PH idea is about OPEN COMMUNITY. That's why we have discussions and not private messages
AI With Vibes
@nataliekarakina @arokor Exactly maybe something not too evasive
for instance you must have at least 200 points to send a DM and each new DM is like 50 Point
AI With Vibes
@nataliekarakina Hmm... I get that idea but most people might not want to share their Mail to during an Open conversation
Adrapid
@nataliekarakina Agree! I think there are many other means to communicate in private.
InAppStory
@repreneur you always can reach person on Twitter in private :)
I believe that the PH thought is about OC, Thats why we have conversations and not private messages
https://dnd5echaractersheet.me/
https://narutofillerlist.net/
AI With Vibes
@mathewperry Hmm.. true that
I think if private messaging is encouraged, the USP of PH will get lost somewhere...
AI With Vibes
@kate_jonas The open community aspect
Honestly if it needs to be sent via DM, it probably doesn’t belong on PH. I love the community dynamic here, and I attribute a large part of it to open, honest discussion 👊
AI With Vibes
@richard_francis2 Hmm ok i actually respect that aspect of PH
maybe we can have a live chat section
AI With Vibes
@oscarcasandram Exactly