Get established product hunter or launch myself?

Slim Geransar
34 replies
Any thoughts here? Wondering if I should launch myself or have an established product hunter help launch? Thanks!

Replies

Angi Bowman
Hunters have a lot of benefits, but you aren't screwed if you opt against it. If you look at the top hunters, they have some amazing successes and some duds. It's the same if you hunt yourself. I agree that building a community is the real key, but unfortunately that's easier said than done.
@lucky__angi I kind of like the idea of doing it myself and not relying on a hunter. I still have a two months of building a solid support group by helping as many people as I can
Joe
If there are any hunters who are particularly active in this space, for us, it's Design. Please reach out to one of them and ask nicely. The Product Hunt community is great and really does help each other out.
Neel Patel
You should be fine either way I think.
@neelptl2602 thanks, just need to build a great support community
Nicolò Marchesi
IMHO, product hunters today aren't worth it if you are active on the community and make lots of friends :)
@pethron thanks, that’s what I’m really trying to cultivate. A community through authentic good old fashioned participation in discussions.
@kate_ramakaieva interested. Any thoughts on why less value now?
Kate Ramakaieva
FuseBase /formerly Nimbus/
@slimmy82 algrorithm has changed and now hunter's suscribers don't receive the email in the launch day as far as I know
Kate Ramakaieva
FuseBase /formerly Nimbus/
@pethron they used to have more value before but now it has changed
@kate_ramakaieva very interesting. Thanks for sharing
Huudle AI Project Assistant
Launch yourself 🤞🏻
@parilti_erkan thanks, that’s what I’m leaning towards.
qiufeng
If you social media, or have a lot of private groups, then by all means
@qiufeng thanks, trying le average every support i can. Thanks for the comment
Annie Chopra
You just have to make sure its someone who is incredibly active within the community. I do think success is possible either way. I have seen hunters with thousands of followers hunt a product that ends up on no.20 for example, and I have seen some hit no.1 - i think you also have to be strategic that the hunter is someone who actually cares about your product thus the community would relate to the product! But i think success is possible by yourself too
@annie_chopra great advice. Thanks. I did check a few hunters launches and some had less than 100 upvotes while some had 500+.
AmazingSylvia
I think both are fine, and get through the process is the best part of this journey
@sylvia_sheng I’m excited and nervous. Hopping to get support from the community I’ve come to support
Daniel Zaitzow
The age old quandary - I'll probably see what engagement looks like prior to rolling out and if I am concerned - I might reach out to a few hunters.
@dzaitzow very valid. I think unless I find some really suitable hunter I’m going to attempt myself.
Daniel Zaitzow
@slimmy82 Probably where I'll land as well.
Mansi Trivedi
Depends... You can do fine both ways. If you feel like you could use some help, you don't really have to get a hunter. You can ask the community members to have a chat.
@mansi_trivedi1 I’m actually wanting to try get some people from the community to look at the product images I want to upload to make sure it tells a compelling story
Mansi Trivedi
@slimmy82 That's great! You can connect with them on Twitter (X) or LinkedIn and take feedback. Here's mine if you wanna connect. https://twitter.com/mansitrivedi07 https://www.linkedin.com/in/mans...
Jaspar Carmichael-Jack
Reduced Burden: Partnering with a hunter can take a significant load off your shoulders, allowing you to focus on other aspects of your business. Expert Guidance: Experienced hunters can provide valuable insights and guidance throughout the launch process. They can help you optimize your product listing, craft compelling messaging, and engage with the Product Hunt community effectively. Increased Exposure: Established Product Hunt hunters have a proven track record of generating buzz and driving traffic to Product Hunt launches. They have a large network of followers and connections who are likely to upvote and comment on your product.
@jasparcj thanks for the insightful comment. I definitely see the value depending on how much they charge (not sure if that’s a thing). Especially if you are not actively trying to build a community. If you plan to join and launch a product the next day, then a hunter is probably a way better option.
Kirill Grebenjukov
On top of my head I see 3 ways to make informed decision: 1. Look the top 3 for last 30+ days and collect how many products was launched by a hunter 2. Look at products of top and medium hunters. And collect proportion of top ranked products 3. Ask teams who launched by a hunter about theirs experience
@kgrebenjukov good action plan. Thanks for taking the time to post
Shivam Garg
I recommend you give it a shot on your own. We recently launched our product independently and achieved a commendable feat, garnering 1300+ upvotes within 24 hours.
@meshivamgarg that’s massive. How long did you and your team spend building an audience?