What’s your take on AI art and content creation—does it add value, or does it lack authenticity?

Question

TJ Larkin · Accepted Answer

I see AI as a thinking and creation partner, not a replacement for authentic expression. For example, when I write, AI helps me organize thoughts and explore angles, but the insights come from real experience. It doesn't really matter if it's a paintbrush or a prompt, authenticity will be present in the story you're telling because you're telling it from your experience. The best we can do is be honest about AI being part of the process.

Rogelio Paulo Jr. Gesmundo · Answer

AI tools enable people like me, who may not have artistic skills, to easily create "art or content", which opens the door for more voices and ideas to be shared. They also assist artists and businesses in producing work more quickly and cost-effectively, boosting productivity.

Moreover, AI can spark new ideas and techniques, fostering innovative artistic expressions. However, some argue that AI-generated art or content creation lacks the emotional depth and personal touch that human artists bring, which can make it seem less authentic.

Ultimately, as mentioned in previous responses and discussions, achieving a balance between AI and Human Creativity / Experience is essential for it to be viewed as truly authentic.

Alex Prompt · Answer

I agree with TJ—AI tools, at their best, are more like co-creators than standalone artists or authors. They’re amazing at helping generate ideas, structure, or even polishing rough drafts, but the spark of authenticity still comes from the human input.

In content creation, I think AI shines in the early stages—like brainstorming or creating iterations to choose from. The value it adds is undeniable, especially when time is tight or you’re stuck in a creative block. But when it comes to final touches, human insight and personal experience are what make the result feel real and relatable.

So, I’d say AI doesn’t lack authenticity—it just depends on how it’s used. If creators treat it like a tool rather than a crutch, it adds a ton of value. What about you, Austin? Do you think the line between "authentic" and "AI-generated" is getting blurry?

Meduard · Answer

Imo it lacks authenticity a lot. With the right prompts you can improve quite a bit, but still without modifying it, it just feels way too generic.

Sergey Koshevoy · Answer

AI is revolutionizing art and content creation by boosting efficiency and accessibility, offering new tools for creators and businesses alike. However, critics argue it lacks the emotional depth and originality of human work, sparking debates about its authenticity and ethical implications.

Janak Patel · Answer

AI art adds value by speeding up creativity and democratizing tools, but it can feel less authentic without a human touch or unique perspective.

Elara Thorn · Answer

It depends on how one utilizes AI. If AI is treated as a collaborator rather than a substitute, by combining human ingenuity and emotional depth with the efficiency and innovation of AI, then creators can create work that is both valuable and authentic.

Answer

AI art and content creation can be valuable for inspiration and scaling creativity, but it lacks the personal touch and emotional depth that comes from human creators.

Tatiana Vdovychenko · Answer

While critics argue it lacks the authenticity of human intention, I see it differently: AI captures patterns and possibilities, turning them into a playground for artists and creators. The authenticity comes not from the tool itself but from how we use it. Think of it as a creative partnership. AI sketches the frame, but it’s up to us to add the soul. Whether it’s value or gimmickry depends on the hands wielding it. For me, the real question isn’t if it adds value, but how much more value we can unlock when humans and AI co-create. Here's a good article on how to interact with image-generating AI to get something as close to your query as possible: https://jetsoftpro.com/blog/ai-i...

MaryFord · Answer

That's a really interesting question! I think AI in art and content creation is like any other tool—it can be used in ways that add incredible value or in ways that might feel a bit lacking in authenticity. On one hand, AI can help artists experiment with new styles, generate ideas, or even complete projects at a scale that would be impossible to achieve by hand. It can democratize access to creative tools, allowing more people to express themselves.

On the other hand, there's a concern about the loss of the human touch, the unique perspective and emotion that comes from personal experience. Some argue that AI-generated content can sometimes feel formulaic or lack the depth and nuance that comes from human creativity. But then again, isn't part of the beauty of art its ability to evolve and adapt to new technologies?

I think it all comes down to how we use these tools. When AI is used as an extension of human creativity, rather than a replacement, it can lead to some truly amazing and innovative work. What do you think? How do you see AI impacting the world of art and content creation?

What’s your take on AI art and content creation—does it add value, or does it lack authenticity?

Replies