How do you feel about people using LLMs to comment on a discussion?

Question

Jake Hamilton-Daynes · Accepted Answer

I think it's lazy - if I'm going to have a conversation with someone, I want to have it with them, not an LLM.

hafid Ahlaqach · Answer

@rebaika_james I think humans know how to connect with other humans best. and using LLMs you will never have a similar connection

hafid Ahlaqach · Answer

@rebaika_james I think humans know how to connect with other humans best and using LLMs just kills this connection

hafid Ahlaqach · Answer

@mercy_james3 Yes i agree about the repetitive questions. but if for example i am asking for a human feedback and someone just generates an answer out of thin air with an llm is confusing

hafid Ahlaqach · Answer

@aisha_kabir I feel like talking to an LLM is just a waste of time. and it gets obvious. getting to interact with another human is valuable

hafid Ahlaqach · Answer

@rothit_kumar_cd yeah, the biggest problem with LLM's is that they will never say things like : "i am not sure" or "i don't know"

hafid Ahlaqach · Answer

@sultan_ansari_ There is nothing well researched about an LLM's response. LLMs can't say i don't know. Humans can just be genuine if someone is seeking another human interaction

hafid Ahlaqach · Answer

@jakeishd I 100% agree with this!

Rebaika James · Answer

I believe LLMs can add value by generating thoughtful responses quickly.

Gurkaran Singh · Answer

Hey, using LLMs in a discussion is like bringing a Swiss Army knife to a coding party - versatile, but might raise a few eyebrows! Nonetheless, it's all in good techno-fun!

Answer

I feel that LLMs can bring a lot of knowledge to discussions, but they need to be used ethically. Ensuring they don’t drown out human voices is important.

Answer

I see the potential benefits of using LLMs to comment, such as maintaining active discussions. But, there should be a way to identify AI-generated content

Answer

I’m open to LLMs being used for comments, but I worry about the loss of personal touch. Ensuring a mix of human and AI responses might be the best approach.

Answer

I’m okay with LLMs being used to comment as long as it’s disclosed.

Answer

I think LLMs can be useful for handling repetitive questions or providing quick answers. However, they shouldn’t replace genuine human engagement.

How do you feel about people using LLMs to comment on a discussion?

Replies