What motivates users to open emails: the subject line, the sender, or the content?

Question

I have been working on emaildojo.io tool for a while now and learned few tricks that email marketers use to maximize their open rates. So, now I'm curious to hear your thoughts on what motivates users to open emails. Specifically, I'm wondering which of the following factors is most important: the subject line, sender name, or email content. As a community of tech enthusiasts and entrepreneurs, I thought this would be a great place to discuss email marketing strategies and hear your insights. Looking forward to your responses!

Rohan Chaubey · Accepted Answer

I first see the subject, immediately after I see the sender and then the content.

Shailendra Singh · Answer

Open rate are purely dictated by subject lines. Reply rates are determined by email content. Sender name / gender has a role to play though very marginally on open rates.

I say this as an email marketer having run email campaigns around 75% - 80% open rates and close to 5% reply rates over 5000+ sent emails.

Gaurav Bhawnani · Answer

If you're reaching out cold mostly its subject lines imo. But lately I've observed (no data to back this) that its actually dependent on how different users use mail clients. For example if you have an unread first kind of setup on your client you're most likely to open all emails just to get them out of your way.

Igor Pavlov · Answer

Subjective opinion: sender. If I trust the sender, I would read an email from them because I believe it has value.

Vikram Sahu ꩜ · Answer

@salem_watsons I don’t know how this is related to my question. I think this is more of self-promotion.

Fred Mulder · Answer

The answer to the question is ambiguous. Some consider the subject line to be one of the most important elements of a sales letter, others believe that it is not as important as the content written inside. It is also important to weed out the maximum number of non-existent email addresses. For example, I use https://www.atompark.com/bulk-em... for such tasks, it helps me a lot to set up the right business connections.

Vikram Sahu ꩜ · Answer

Thanks, @shailendra_singh_ht for sharing your insights on email marketing! It's great to hear that you've been able to achieve such high open and reply rates in your campaigns. I'm curious, what strategies do you use to craft effective subject lines and email content that resonates with your audience? Any tips or best practices you could share?

Vikram Sahu ꩜ · Answer

@rohanrecommends Thanks for your thoughts.

I think this highlights the importance of crafting a compelling subject line and establishing a clear and recognizable sender name when sending emails.

Also, it is crucial that the email's content adds value to the recipient and is formatted in a clear, easy-to-read way to maximize the likelihood that the recipient will open and interact with it.

Vikram Sahu ꩜ · Answer

@igorpavlov Agree, If you trust the sender, you are more likely to believe that the email they sent has value and is worth reading.

I, too, prioritize the sender name over the subject line when reading emails. This is because, with the advancements in AI, anyone can come up with a catchy subject line that does not necessarily represent the true value of the email content. Therefore, knowing the sender's name helps me determine if the email is trustworthy and worth my time.

What motivates users to open emails: the subject line, the sender, or the content?

Replies